Payless: Buy 1 Get 1 50% off Sale + Additional 20% off Entire Order & 8% Cash Back

Hip2Save may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you via trusted partners and affiliate links in this post. Prices and availability are accurate as of time posted. Read our full disclosure policy here.

Currently, Payless Shoesource (or go through ShopAtHome.com to score 8% cash back!) is offering up a buy 1 get 1 50% off sale on everything on their site! Even sweeter, you can score an additional 20% off your entire order with the promo code 72502 during checkout. AND, you can even choose to have your order shipped to your local Payless store to bypass all shipping costs (otherwise just pay a flat rate of $5.95)!

If you have a little girl who likes sparkles and flip flops, then you’re in luck! Check out this deal scenario that I cooked up just for you:

Buy 2 pairs of American Eagle Girls’ Lunar Glitter Flip Flops as pictured above on sale for $5 each
(choose from pink, silver or gold)
Total After B1G1 50% Off Sale = $7.50
Enter the promo code 72502 at checkout
Choose free site to store shipping for free
Final Cost $6 (just $3 per pair!)

Here a few other deal ideas…

Buy 2 Women’s American Eagle Sparkle Flip Flops on sale for $6 each
After all discounts and free store pickup – Only $7.20- that makes each pair just $3.60!


Buy 2 Girls’ Princess Rapunzel or Hello Kitty Bow Sunglasses on sale for $2.99 each
After all discounts and free store pickup – Only $3.59 total – that makes each pair just $1.79!

Buy 2 Boys’ Avengers EVA Flip Flops on sale $5.99 each
After all discounts and free store pickup – only $7.20 for 2 pairs – just $3.60 each!

Buy 2 Boys’ and/or Girls’ Umbrellas $9.99 each
After all discounts and free store pickup – only $11.99 for both – just $6 per umbrella!

Come back to let us know what bargains you score!

Join The Discussion

Comments 28

  1. Su

    Any idea how long it takes to get your order if you choose in store pick up?

    • Collin (Mrs. Hip)

      According to the site, you need to allow 14-17 days.

    • Kay

      It looks like it says 14-17 days.

  2. Kay

    Anyone know what their return policy is if the shoes don’t fit? tia

    • Collin (Mrs. Hip)

      This is direct from the Payless site:

      Payless.com offers the easiest return policy because of our thousands of store locations nationwide. No re-boxing, re-labeling, mailing or waiting for processing. Just bring your Payless.com purchase into a store near you for an instant refund.

      When returning or exchanging an item in-store, please bring:

      The original packing slip/receipt
      The credit card used to purchase the item
      The item to return or exchange

      All refunds will be credited to the card used to make the original purchase

      Hope this helps! 😀

      • Ren

        Payless does have a fantastic return policy. I’ve had very positive experiences with them when I had to return shoes.

    • Kay

      Found it. Looks like they will take them back for a full refund! Ordering now – thaks Collin!!

    • Julie

      I once returned a pair of VERY used sandles that my daughter had worn. The strap on them broke. They exchanged them for the exact same pair without a receipt. No questions asked!

      • Kimberly

        I used to work at payless (about 7 years ago) and IMO they have the best/easiest return policy and will almost always take care of their customers. I only say almost because in some instances (such as stores located in high theft areas) they will be a little more cautious of returns. 🙂

  3. Suzanne

    The umbrellas would be $14.99 total, not $11.99. Buy one at $9.99, get one HALF off at $5.00 = $14.99.

    • Suzanne

      I just read the top, I’m an idiot :'(

      • Collin (Mrs. Hip)

        LOL! Glad that you figured it out. 😀

      • Kay

        I spoke too soon too! I think we just get so excited with all the hip deals!! ha ha 🙂

  4. Rain

    Well dangit… just went to Payless for BOGO yesterday… should have known Collin would come up with a special code lol 🙂

  5. sne3103

    Just ordered 2 pairs of the women’s flip flops… they look so cute! Thanks Collin 😀

    • wendy

      I have been wanting to get some colorful new sandals/flip flops for this summer. Have been waiting for some good shoes on clearance at target to use the BOGO50% in store coupon, haven’t had any luck yet. So THANKS Collin!! got one of each pair of those colorful American Eagles for only $9!!! YOU MADE MY DAY!! =)

  6. Sarah

    Just an FYI this American Eagle brand is NOT affiliated with American Eagle Outfitters. Payless has actually been sued in the past for copyright infringement by AEO. Just wanted to throw that out there in case some people missed the fine print 🙂

  7. Sarah

    I like the kids sparkle sandals better than the adult version, sizes left are youth 11,12,13, does anyone know what sizes those are in adult?

    • heather

      i think those are like toddler size, after a 13 is a 1, 2, 3, 4 , a four is equal to a ladys 5 – 5.5 and a 5 is equal to a lady 6 – 6.5 or so i have found it to be. i wear a 6.5 ladys and can were a 5 in girls.

      • ali

        I knew a Heather that could wear a size 5 in girls once…what are the chances that it is you?!? Did you live in Colorado before?

  8. tiffany

    Just an FYI the AE Womens flip flops are very very narrow!

  9. Caryn F.

    I just got 4 pairs of sandals for $19!!!! I love sandals I’m so excited!! It ended up being a little over $4 per sandal! 🙂 Yay!

  10. Rebecca

    Thanks for the code Collin! I’m a Payless lifer & love it. I’ve been needing a new pair of black heels as mine are literally falling apart. I got the blue Fioni Night Krista Platforms in store recently (on BOGO with Dora sneakers for DD). I love them and they’re actually comfortable while looking HOT! I couldn’t rationalize getting myself the black pair too (though needed) until this triple deal (BOGO again with the same Dora sneakers for DD but the next size up so she’ll have them once she outgrows her current ones since she LOVES them). So thank you! 😀

    • Rebecca

      Oh yeah, my deal on my heals & DD’s sneakers:
      $23.99 + $1.68tax = $25.67 TOTAL
      for $49.98 worth of shoes -not including tax. 🙂

      • Rebecca

        Not to mention the 8% SAH cashback to boot! 😛

  11. ali

    Found some cute boys Airwalk surf moc slip-ons on for $6.00, down from $19.99. (didn’t show up when I did a low-to-high search by size range in the SALE heading, but showed up when I just went to the regular BOYS heading and under “styles”, hit “view all”, then do low-to-high price). Grabbed 2 pairs in different sizes and paid $7.20 total for both pairs, plus the 8% cash back from shopathome! They had a few other styles that showed up in that search that didn’t come up for me when I just went to the SALE heading and searched low-to-high…weird, but I’m happy I found them!

  12. Karen

    Four pairs of boys sunglasses for just over ten bucks. The Thomas ones were on clearance for 2.99 so just 1.50 for second pair!

  13. Nicole

    Is this Just on line or can we use this in the store as well

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

It's not your Grandma's coupon site!

Sign up for a Hip2Save account (it's free) to access all of the awesome features!

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot Password

Don't have an account? Register

Become a Hip2Save Insider

Don't Miss Out! Join our large community of insiders - it's totally free! Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! What are ya waiting for?!



Already have an account? Login

Thank you for rating!

Would you also like to leave us a comment?