We Spotted NEW Harry Potter Coffee Mate Flavors

By Kelli | Staff Writer

Aug 01, 2025 @ 2:50 PM MDT

Hip2Save may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you via trusted partners and affiliate links in this post. Prices and availability are accurate as of time posted. Read our full disclosure policy here.

Check out the latest Coffee Mate flavor!

A person touching a blue and purple bottle of coffee creamer in cooler

Whether you’re a wizard, witch, or mere Muggle, these NEW Coffee Mate non-dairy creamers inspired by the Wizarding World will make every morning a bit more magical.

Add some sweet toffee to your coffee with Cauldron Cake, or Zero Sugar Peppermint Toad, swirling with white chocolate and peppermint enchantment (no toads were harmed, promise!). 🪄✨

We’ve spotted them at our local grocery store, but word by owl says they’ll soon apparate onto shelves everywhere! 🧙‍♂️✨

Brew up a bit of everyday magic 🪄

Coffee Mate Harry Potter Cauldron Cake Toffee Flavored Creamer 28oz
Just $5 – in-store only!

*Note that you can find this on Walmart.com, however, availability varies.

A person holding a blue bottle of coffee creamer in a store

Coffee Mate Harry Potter Peppermint Toad Flavored Creamer 28oz
Just $5 – in-store only!

Fit for Gryffindors, Slytherins, Ravenclaws, and Hufflepuffs alike, these non-dairy, gluten-free potion transforms hot coffee, iced brews, or dessert drinks into something truly spellbinding.

Decide if you’ll share your secret or keep the magic all to yourself, but get it quickly, before they disappear…

Here’s what else is trending in the food & beverage world >>>

About the writer:

Kelli is a content writer with a degree in English Education from Penn State University. When she’s not hunting for great deals, this proud Mom and Gigi is off gallivanting in the family RV chasing history, quirky roadside attractions, and the oddest museums she can find.