*HOT* Deal on Furreal Friends Butterscotch Pony – Only $49.99 (+ Shipping)

Hip2Save may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you via trusted partners and affiliate links in this post. Prices and availability are accurate as of time posted. Read our full disclosure policy here.

UPDATE: After reading through the comments, this pony does appear to be ringing up for $49.99 in-store. I am not sure how long this will last or if these are even in-stock at your local Target, so I would suggest calling before you head on over there.

Wow! If you’ve been waiting for a great deal on the Furreal Friends Baby Butterscotch My Magical Show Pony Pet, then today is your lucky day! Hurry on over to and add the Baby Butterscotch My Magical Show Pony Pet to your cart for only $49.99 (reg. $119.99!). Note that you will need to pay shipping costs of $8.95 unless you are a Target REDcard holder in which case you will score FREE shipping AND 5% off automatically – no minimum for being a cardholder. Sweet! ๐Ÿ˜€

As a price comparison, this same Pony Pet is selling for $126 on and is rated 4 out of 5 stars by over 30 reviewers. It also sells for $99 over at with great reviews.

Go through to score 4% cash back or go through to score 2% cash back.

* Also keep in mind that if you are planning to shop at your local Target store today, you may want to see if you can find this same item in-store for this low price of $49.99 as reader, Andi, was able to find it at this price in her local Target today.

(Thanks, Andi!)

Join The Discussion

Comments 56

  1. kristy

    Do you know how long this sale lasts plz?

  2. Samantha

    So excited for this! My hubby & I were so bummed to see it was $120. Made our weekend! Thank you!!!

  3. Jennifer

    Just got one this morning at my Target near Raleigh, NC for 49.99…great deal if you ask me!

  4. Michelle P

    THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!! This is the one thing my 4 year old really wants for Christmas and I really didn’t want to spend $100!

  5. Samantha

    Went to order & the price is now $99 ๐Ÿ™

  6. ch

    i have it in my cart them they just change to $99…hmmm

  7. lisa

    it is showing up at $99 in my cart, anyone else having this issue?

    • Candace

      $99 for me too :/

  8. katie


  9. Ashley P.

    Price just changed!

  10. Stephanie

    I added it to my cart when I saw it at $49.99…looked at a couple other things and now its saying its $99.00? Maybe they priced it wrong? Or maybe the website is messing up….anyone else having problems with it? I’ll just keep an eye on it and see if it goes lower again ๐Ÿ™

  11. Cynthia Huling

    99.00 bummer!

  12. Michele

    It must have been a mistake it’s $99 now. boo hoo

  13. mary

    I’m curious…what makes these so great? I can’t believe they are normally over $100!

  14. Janelle

    I got all the way through the checkout process and at the last second it jumped to $99. I called and they were no help at all. I am really disappointed. I understand if you change the price but not during checkout.

  15. Bethany

    I just was on the phone with Target and although they could see the price had been $49.99, I was told it was a mistake and they could not honor it.

  16. Virginia

    Check your store mine rang up at $49 just 2 minutes ago!

  17. kendall

    I got one in our local store for $49

  18. Chrys Lewis

    I just got home from the store and got it for $49.99.

  19. Jennifer

    Got it at the store for $49.99!

  20. Renee

    I got one at my store too for $49.99! I’m in the St. Louis, MO area.

  21. Jackie

    The Razor Scooter showed $34.99, after I put in the code it took $10 off, how come the price is different then the one you posted?

  22. lisa

    I also just bought one at my local store for $49.99. I believe the tag said price cut from 11/18 through 12/24!

  23. bettyj

    As soon as I saw this and that it was expired and that you might could get at the store I jumped right in the car and drove to Target. They were marked down to 49.99 but did not have any on shelf. I called someone to look for me and they went in back and brought out two. It rang up for 49.99 and she used the 5 coupon in the toy book. It went right thru so it was 44.99 and then with my target debit it went down another 2.25. Thank you. I just got back home with it so this was about 1:00 p.m. I also got the pretty princess play-doh on sale for 13.99 and brought that down to 10.99. Thank you again. My Christmas gifts would not be half as great as they are going to be without you. If you have a local store try there.

    • Jessica

      Have one on hold in store… Saw someone used the $5 off Furreal coupon for the pony, but it says it’s excluded. Has anyone else had any luck?

      • semiextremecouponer

        There’s a $5 off $50 coupon that peels off the ad. It expires 11/21

  24. rachael

    Got one at the store too!

  25. Shannon

    I just got one in the store. $49.99!!

  26. Jen

    Hello, I just snagged this pony at my local Target for the sale price $50.Call your local store,it’s worth the phone call to see!Good luck!

  27. Jen

    Hello, I just snagged this pony at my local Target for the sale price $50.Call your local store,it’s worth the phone call to see!Good luck

  28. Anna

    It was not a mistake…that’s the price in the store. Just call your store before you go. Also, at the store I went to, the boxes were all mashed up, but I found one on the top of the shelves. Always try to look up…those are also the toys not likely played with once they are put out on the shelves!

    Thanks for the deal!! Shocked it wasn’t advertised! ๐Ÿ™‚

  29. Ali

    I just went to our store and found one. They had a sign that said limited time offer $49.99 … Thank you!!!

  30. RH

    man, going to have to make a trip to Target….

  31. Amelia

    Thank you so much for the heads up! I was able to run to the store and grab the last one ๐Ÿ™‚

  32. Adrian

    THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!!! This was at the top of my daughter’s Christmas list and out of our budget because of everything else I had bought her during the year. I just ran to our one and only Target with my daughter in tow. I grabbed two large bath towels on the way to the toy aisle. I spotted it out of the corner of my eye, made her turn her back and I threw it in the cart, covered it with the bath towels and headed to the check-out with her walking in front of the cart.

    Once we got to the check-out the salesgirl was SO helpful in trying to find something that could cover the box, so I could get it to the car without my daughter seeing it. All the while another salesgirl was keeping an eye on my daughter so she wouldn’t peek! In the end my salesgirl came out to our car with us with the bath towels (that I did not purchase) still over Butterscotch, the salesgirl helped my daughter get in the car, while I put it in the trunk, then I handed off the bath towels and we both went on our way! It was quite the rush and I was so thankful to be able to get her something that she really wants! Thank you Collin for posting all of these great deals! I seriously could not do Christmas without you!!!

  33. Amber

    Thank you sooooooo much for posting this and to all of you who left comments saying you found it in store for that price. My daughter said all she wants for her birthday is the butterscotch pony but I just couldn’t bring myself to pay between 100 and 130 for it so I just kept telling her we’ll see. After reading this post I sent my husband to Target and he got the last one and it was priced at 49.99. She is gonna be, in her terms, “freaking out” when she sees it. December is such a hard month for us with my daughters birthday, our anniversary, Hanukkah and Christmas. Thanks to Collin and all of you hip2savers out there this year will be much easier. Happy Holidays everyone!

  34. Jenine

    Got one too at the store!!! THANK YOU!!! I can’t thank u enough. I was prepping my 6 year daughter that Santa was not going to bring this. I just couldn’t spend $119 on one toy!!! Thank you so much you just made one little girl’s Christmas morning unbelievable!!

  35. Erica

    Just sent my husband to check. The toy dept couldn’t get me an answer after 10 min if being on hold. Just bought at Walmart today for $99. Fingers crossed they have it so I can take it back to Walmart. Thank you for posting this. Just what my daughter asked Samta for.

  36. Andi

    So excited so many hip2savers were able to find this deal. I shot Collin an email once I got home from Target this morning hoping it wasn’t a fluke at my store. I was literally jumping up and down in the aisle with another woman this morning when we saw the price cut tag. Thank you Collin for all you do for us!

  37. Tomoko

    I sent my hubby to Target and he got the last one they had!! He used a $5/$50 peelie from the toy book and then cashier let him use a $5 off Furreal coupon ( I didn’t expect this). He got it for $37.75 with red card. Woot woot!! My daughter will be so surprise. Can’t wait to see her face on Christmas morning.Thank you so much Collin and Andi!

  38. Giselle

    Just got back from my store with a Butterscotch! My 5 year old really wants this for Christmas and I tried to explain to her that maybe Santa wouldn’t have room (aka it was way too expensive!) but she couldn’t stop talking about Butterscotch. So excited to be able to get it for her.

  39. Stephanie

    Walmart will price match the in store price won’t they?! My local Target was out of stock today when I checked.

    • Tara

      You could always try. Maybe try taking a picture oif the price cut sign if u have a smartphone and showing it to them

  40. Megan

    So this was marked as $99 at my local store (western wa) when scanned it rang up as $49.99!! Got the last one on the shelf.. can’t tell you how much this helps!!!! If you call for a price check.. make sure they scan it!! After the past 24 hours I had.. this just totally made my day!!

  41. Jennifer

    Got one at my local Target today. My 4 year old will be so excited! Thank you Collin for all that you and your helpers do to make it possible for us to get these awesome deals!!

  42. Michelle

    I just got 5 at Hillsboro, or target. They said it’s a 4 day sale and the price wasn’t marked on the shelf.

    • Em

      You’re going to have 5 really happy kiddos! I went to 2 Targets, but no dice, all sold out!

  43. Kristy

    Still working in store in ohio at 9:00 am!!!

  44. Jenn

    I saw this last night at about 11 PM and was bummed because I didn’t think the store would still have it at this price especially if online price changed back to $99 yesterday. But my hubby just picked one up this morning (9AM CST) at Target store in NE Minneapolis for $49.99! I am shocked as I honestly think the price is a mistake but maybe it just hasn’t caught up to the stores yet. My almost 5 year old is going to be SO thrilled! Thank you for continuing to bring us toy deals throughout the season ๐Ÿ™‚

  45. Melody

    I checked our Target this morning in Springfield, MO and their was one left. I grabbed it and it rang up for $49.00 and I had a $5.00 coupon! Went over to Toys R Us and they had the same one for $99.00. GREAT SAVINGS AT TARGET!

  46. JJ

    My Target was all out & I called one 40 mins away. They were out as well. I called manager at Walmart to price match the same item at Walmart store since they had a ton. The Walmart manager called & confirmed the price at Target. Got it for the same price! ๐Ÿ™‚ Hope this helps!

  47. jenniferlandrews

    I got one in my store here in Omaha for 49.99! It was the last one on the shelf. It wasn’t working (you are supposed to be able to pet her back and she moves or talks or something), so I am hoping that is just a batteries issue, or a quick exchange issue. Either way, I got it at the lower price. Also, FYI, there was a sale sign on the shelf indicating it was 49.99, down from 119.99.

  48. Linda Stutts

    I called Target as soon as I saw the post and they had 1 left which they agreed to hold until my husband could get there. Didn’t know about the other q’s but very happy to get it for $49.99! Thanks so much for the tip, a great way to start Christmas shopping!

  49. Erin

    Went today and got one. The price cut tag said that price is valid until 12/25/12!

  50. alexis

    Went to the store today and it rang at 99.99 ๐Ÿ™ May still try and price match at Walmart since I have a pic of the shelf tag and promotion dates

    • Rachel

      Does any body have the promotion dates or kind of ad or something

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

It's not your Grandma's coupon site!

Sign up for a Hip2Save account (it's free) to access all of the awesome features!

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot Password

Don't have an account? Register

Become a Hip2Save Insider

Don't Miss Out! Join our large community of insiders - it's totally free! Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! What are ya waiting for?!

Already have an account? Login

Thank you for rating!

Would you also like to leave us a comment?