Don't miss a deal!

Subscribe to our newsletter.

Sam’s Club Vs Walmart: Which Store Offers the Biggest Savings On Ice Cream Treats?

Hip2Save may earn a small commission via affiliate links in this post. Read our full disclosure policy here.

Shopping for a sweet treat to stash in the freezer this summer?

Through June 2nd, Sam’s Club is offering up some great deals on Ice Cream Treats both in-store and online! Note that the instant savings will automatically be deducted at checkout and some deals are available in club only.

Wondering if these deals beat Walmart’s prices? We did the comparison shopping for you!

We headed to our local Walmart store to compare the prices of buying in bulk from Sam’s Club vs. buying the smaller boxes at Walmart. Check out our clear findings below!

Sam’s Club VERSUS Walmart:

Outshine Fruit Bars 24-Pack $9.98 at Sam’s Club
Minus $2 Instant Savings at Checkout
Final cost $7.98 – just 33¢ per bar!

VERSUS

Outshine Fruit Bars 6-Pack $3.48 at Walmart 
Final cost – 58¢ per bar!


Klondike The Original Ice Cream Bar 4.5 oz 24-Count $10.98 at Sam’s Club
Minus $2 Instant Savings at Checkout
Final cost $8.98 – just 37¢ per bar!

VERSUS

Klondike The Original Ice Cream Bar 4.5 oz 18-Count $7.74 at Walmart
Final cost – just 43¢ per bar!


Nestle Drumstick Ice Cream Treats 24-Count $9.98 at Sam’s Club
Minus $2 Instant Savings at Checkout
Final cost $7.98 – just 41¢ each!

VERSUS

Nestle Drumstick Ice Cream Treats 8-Count $5.97 at Walmart
Final cost – 75¢ each!


Nestle Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches 12-Count $9.98 at Sam’s Club
Minus $2 Instant Savings at Checkout
Final cost $7.98 – just 66¢ each!

VERSUS

Nestle Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches 7-Count $6.48 at Walmart
Final cost – 92¢ each!


Kit Kat Ice Cream Cones 16-Count $9.98 at Sam’s Club
Minus $2 Instant Savings at Checkout
Final cost $7.98 – just 50¢ each!

VERSUS

Kit Kat Ice Cream Cones 8-Count $6.48 at Walmart
Final cost – 81¢ each!


The Final Verdict —> Sam’s Club is the clear winner! 🏆 Don’t miss out though – as the deals are only good through June 2nd!

  • Shipping Info

    Sam's Club

    Choose free pick-up at your local Sam’s Club if available; otherwise, shipping varies by zip code or is free for Sam’s Plus members.

Join The Discussion

Comments 22

  1. Amber

    If I was paying for a membership and buying in bulk, I would expect it to be cheaper than Walmart.

    • Lo

      Agree. And I think the price comparison should be done by full everyday price not the sale.

      • Juma

        Agree also plus the item amounts aren’t even equal.

        • Bryn (Sister Sidekick)

          Hi there! Since the sizes of the boxes do vary by store, we calculated the final cost at each store based on a per item basis. Hope this makes sense! 🙂

        • mel

          The math will still come out better at Sam’s everyday price, if you buy the comparable amount at WM. Take Outshine bars. ONE 24 ct at Sam’s club = $9.98 (or $0.41 per bar) is still a FAR better deal than buying (4) 6ct boxes at Walmart @ $3.48 = $13.92, which still comes out to $0.58 per bar.

  2. Kenia

    Does the Nestle Drumsticks have 16 or 24 per box?

    • Cassandra (Hip Sidekick)

      Hi Kenia! The Drumsticks sold at Sam’s Club contain 16 cones per box. Hope that helps!

      • MommySpendsLess

        You may want to check the description/calculations on that comparison. It looks like it’s listed as 24-count in the text.

  3. Joy

    Walmart owns Sam’s club. A lot of these bulk items can also be found at a Super Walmart for a similar price. Better comparison might be Sam’s Club vs. Costco or BJ’s. Although not everyone has one or the other in their regions. All our Sam’s Clubs closed a couple of years ago.

  4. TWood

    I think a comparison would be item for item, same quantity.

    • Bryn (Sister Sidekick)

      Since Sam’s Club and Walmart carry different sized boxes of the same items, we calculated the final cost at each store based on a per item basis.

  5. Jennifer

    Thank you so much Hip2Save for all your research And for doing the math for us all!
    Love you guys! 😍

    • Collin (Mrs. Hip)

      You are SO very welcome, Jennifer! Thanks a bunch for the kind comment! It sure means a lot! 🥰

  6. lk

    I was thinking that the Klondike bars are about $7 or $8 regularly at my Sams. Definitely a far better deal even at full price. I just wish they carried other varieties besides original. We buy them and the drumsticks frequently at Sams.

  7. llc

    off topic but everyone should try the Outshine Blueberry and Acai Flavor. OMG. The best juice pop ever. We can never eat just one.

  8. llc

    off topic but everyone should try the Outshine Blueberry and Acai Flavor. OMG. The best juice pop ever. We can never eat just one.

  9. MommySpendsLess

    Does Sam’s still beat Publix BOGO? It seems like Klondikes have been on sale a lot lately at Publix.

    • Cassandra (Hip Sidekick)

      Great question, MommySpendsLess! I was actually just looking at this last week when I was shopping at Sam’s as my kiddos love these ice cream treats. My Publix usually has them priced at $4.49 for a 6-pack. So you’d pay $4.49 after the BOGO sale which works out to around 35¢ per bar. So the better buy is definitely Sam’s. BUT, Sam’s usually only carries one flavor so if your kiddos prefer anything other than vanilla (like mine), you might be better off buying at Publix. Hope that helps!

  10. Sara

    My husband and I love the Sam’s Club gas. The prices are about $.25 cheaper per gallon and last longer in our cars with the same drive to work every day.

  11. patricialavenz-goff

    You forgot to factor in coupons. I have a $1.50 off one outshine and $1 off two.

  12. patricialavenz-goff

    I just can’t get over paying for a membership…………….

    • Jennifer

      Do you have pets? We make our membership back in a couple months just with savings on pet food.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

It's not your Grandma's coupon site!

Sign up for a Hip2Save account (it's free) to access all of the awesome features!

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot Password

Don't have an account? Register

Become a Hip2Save Insider

Don't Miss Out! Join our large community of insiders - it's totally free! Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! What are ya waiting for?!

Already have an account? Login

Become a Hip2Save Insider

Don't Miss Out! Join our large community of insiders - it's totally free! Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! What are ya waiting for?!



Already have an account? Login

Thank you for rating!

Would you also like to leave us a comment?