Love Oprah’s Favorite Things? These Budget-Friendly Alternatives Will Save You Over $480!
Shop gifts from Oprah’s Favorite Things 2024, but better.
If you’ve ever browsed Oprah’s Favorite Things list, you know that many of those items tend to be pretty pricey and the majority of them aren’t very highly rated either.
We love Oprah, but we have to wonder why so many consumers anticipate her overrated annual gift list because it certainly leaves a lot to be desired.
…Like, that time I bought her $120 jewelry set that broke the first time I wore it… 😳
You deserve better gifts. Check out our top alternatives for 2024:
1.This initial ring is $26 less than Oprah’s pick and can even be personalized.
MELANIE MARiE Adjustable Initial Ring (top) – $36
KeyStyle Adjustable Initial Ring (bottom) – $9.99+
The initial rings have been trending for a couple of years now so it’s no surprise something similar has landed on Oprah’s Favorite Things 2024 list. 😉 However, our pick is much more affordable and available in every letter (unlike Oprah’s, which skips 12!). 😱 Ours also comes in three colors, instead of just one like Oprah’s. Even better, ours can be personalized for just a few dollars more, making it the perfect thoughtful and stylish holiday gift!
“Perfect statement piece for the simplest outfit. These rings are not pricey but on your hands and with the right outfit they can easily elevate your look!”– Indya ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
*Note that while this ring isn’t made of real gold, reviewers recommend reserving it for occasional wear to keep it looking its best.
2. This loungeware is over $100 less than the Softies set Oprah’s Favorite List 2024 features.
Softies Ultra-Soft Marshmallow Lounge Set (top) – $139
luvamia Fuzzy Fleece Loungewear Set (bottom) – $49.99
Clip the 8% OFF digital coupon
Final cost just $45.99 SHIPPED!
Why splurge on the Softies set when our Amazon pick gives you the same cozy vibes at a fraction of the price? Our two-piece loungewear set features a stylish, loose fit for the same high-end look without the hefty price tag. The only difference? Our pick has a flattering curved neckline rather than a V-neck like the Softies set, and honestly, we prefer the curved one.
Plus, our Amazon pick offers multiple color options identical to Softies and beyond. Whether you’re lounging at home, running errands, or need a quick holiday gift, this set delivers ultimate comfort and style without breaking the bank.
“This set of loungewear is ridiculously soft and incredibly comfy—I can’t wait for the weather to cool off so I can live in it! The boucle-type material is so dreamy, I’m already thinking of ordering another color! I even talked my sister into getting a set because I love it so much. For reference, I’m 5’3” and 105 lbs, and the fit is just perfect—not too tight or baggy.” – Tori ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
3. Oprah’s Favorite Things 2024 list has a robe that’s nearly $250, but our pick is the #1 best seller.
Eberjey Renew Plush Long Robe (top) – $248
PAVILIA Premium Plush Soft Robe (bottom) – $29.98
Considering our top pick for a plush robe is the #1 best-seller on Amazon and has well over 7,000 5-star rave reviews, we don’t think Oprah’s pick at nearly $250 deserves a second look. Our pick comes in sizes ranging from small to 3X and is available in 14 different colors whereas Oprah’s has just 2 options. Plus, it’s also machine washable.
“It is really a great bathrobe. The color is very beautiful and the fabric is very warm, soft, and luxurious in every sense of the word. The fabric feels heavy and I love the thick sherpa material that feels like soft wool.” – Mary ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
4. The oversized earmuffs we chose are under $13 and comfortable to wear with earbuds.
Violet & Brooks Foldable Ear Muffs (top) $32
Clip the 20% OFF digital coupon
Final cost $25.60
Brook + Bay Foldable & Furry Ear Muffs (bottom) – $12.95 SHIPPED (reg. $14.95)
Oprah’s favorite ear muffs are currently 20% OFF, but even then, our top pick is still half the cost! Although we don’t own this exact pair of ear muffs, Brook + Bay is a company we’ve personally team-tested and shared deals for over the years so we know they’ll live up to your high expectations. We love that our pick is foldable and can also be worn with earbuds so you’re not compromising on luxury either.
5. The Poppy & Pout gift sets are one thing Oprah got right, but we’d still do it differently to save $60 or more.
Poppy & Pout All Natural Lip Tints, 10 Pack (top) – $99.95
Poppy & Pout All Natural Lip Tints, Love & Light 3 Pack (bottom) – $39.95
Well, there’s one thing Oprah’s Favorite Things list got right. However, we still feel Oprah missed the mark since her list is directing consumers directly to a gift set that costs nearly $100 when there are many more affordable gift sets by the same company.
They offer tinted gift sets in many different shades which we think is more realistic if you know the shades of tinted lip balm you or a giftee will gravitate towards. Plus, they have non-tinted lip balm gift sets (my personal fave) for just $26.95 for three.
That means you’ll pay even less per tube of lip balm with my favorite packs.
Poppy & Pout is a company our team has raved about in the past – I have owned and loved this lip balm for years! It does such a wonderful job at moisturizing my lips, but just as important, their products are completely toxic-free.
Poppy & Pout lip balm, handmade in Idaho, features ethically sourced ingredients like organic coconut oil, beeswax, non-GMO sunflower oil, and vitamin E, all packed into eco-friendly cardboard tubes. Twice the size of standard balms, it delivers long-lasting moisture with subtle, sensitive-friendly scents.
Hip Tip: Clean up your beauty routine with my other favorite non-toxic beauty products!
BONUS: Grab our team’s favorite Quince throw blanket if you don’t mind a splurge. It’s still $68 cheaper than Oprah’s pick & Collin’s fave!
Annie Selke Fab Faux Sand Throw (top) – $158
Quince Ruched Faux Fur Throw (bottom) – $89.90
Our team LOVES Quince bedding so we definitely know this throw blanket is worth the steeper price. Like all Quince products, this stunning throw blanket is ethically made and we love that the entire blanket is made of 100% recycled materials which Oprah’s cannot say.
One side of the Quince throw features a dreamy micro mink and the other, an 850gsm faux fur. It also comes in 4 identical colors to Annie Selke’s which is currently sold out anyway, so there’s no reason to wait for it to be back in stock. Run and grab a Quince before they’re gone!
“This Quince throw blanket is so soft and cozy, and the ruched faux fur design makes it look super luxurious. Plus, at this price, it feels like such a steal for the quality. Highly recommend it if you’re looking to up your cozy game this season or looking for a gift for the person who has everything!” – Collin, Hip2Save CEO & founder
Want to spend even less? Bookmark this Walmart Bubble Throw Blanket for under $25 to stay within budget and get notified when it’s back in stock.
Are you a fan of Oprah’s Favorite Things List? Let us know in the comments!
Love these types of posts! Thanks for all your hard work 🌻
You’re very welcome, Patti! I’m thrilled you enjoyed this post and it was so much fun to put together. 🎁
I just wanted to say, I’m not really as big fan of Oprah’s lately. But, I am a big fan of Hip2Save. For me, Hips opinion is better than Oprah’s. Colin and the rest of you elves are pretty spot on with your posts. Thank you for all you do. Especially those Amazon sweaters pjs etc!!! I will check out the Oprah holiday list because it marks the start of the season. But, for me, I appreciate Hip2Save far more and all year long!!!! 🙏☺️
Aww, thank you so much for your kind words and support, Sue! ❤️ It truly means the world to us that you enjoy the deals and posts we share – especially those awesome Amazon finds! So glad to be a part of your year-round savings journey. 💖 Happy holiday season to you, and thanks again for making our day with your sweet comment! 🎄✨
you guys are the best, thanks for doing this 🙂
You’re most welcome, Jen! 💗 Thank YOU for the kind words! 🤗
Great Post!
Thank you so much, Angela! I’m so glad you enjoyed it! 🤩
Thank you so much for this post!!!
You’re very welcome, EricaA! Thanks for stopping by to leave a sweet comment. 🤗
Been a fan of HIP2SAVE for many years! I look to you for great deals and appreciate all the hard work from your wonderful “elves”. Oprah, on the other hand, is a very polarizing celebrity, and a turn off to half the country, including many of your followers. You don’t need the help of celebrities….you’re already the star of bargains! ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Agreed. I couldn’t care less about Oprah’s favorite things. She ain’t on the budget I’m on. 😅
Aw, thank you so much for being a longtime fan! ❤️ We truly appreciate your kind words about our team of “elves”. This post isn’t about loving Oprah’s picks at all… quite the opposite, actually! 😂 Sara once bought one of her recommendations, and let’s just say it was garbage (lesson learned). These are all lookalikes for WAY less because, let’s be real, who wants to pay Oprah prices? Not most of us! 😅✨
Your posts are amazing! I have purchased a number of things on your recommendations and I’ve never been disappointed! Thank you so much for showing us these more affordable options because paying more doesn’t mean it’s better.
I am a coffee cup freak too! I have. So many! The enjoyment I get from a drink is directly related to what I drink it out of lol
Aw, thank you so much for your kind words, Chris! It truly makes my day to hear that you’ve loved the recommendations—I’m so happy they’ve worked out for you! 🥰 I couldn’t agree more that affordable options can be just as amazing (if not better sometimes!). Cheers to many more finds! ☕💖
Thank you for all the time and effort you put into these posts for us! It is very much appreciate. 🙂
You’re very welcome, Renae! I love getting to do these posts for you all and I love that they’re so well received! Thank you so much for the sweet comment, it made my day! 🥰