The Best Dog Subscription Boxes

Hip2Save may earn a small commission via affiliate links in this post. Read our full disclosure policy here.

More Product Reviews

white dog next to super chewer subscription box

Dogs make us and our families so very happy, so why not return the favor and surprise them with a gift that keeps on giving! Check out these 5 dog subscription boxes (filled with toys and treats!) that we’re loving, and we’ve even got an option for cats, too!


Here are the best monthly subscription boxes dogs are raving about:

1. BarkBox

small brown and white dog sitting next to barkbox

What is BarkBox?

Do you or your pup love themes? With BarkBox, you’ll receive a different themed box every month including 2 innovative toys, 2 all-natural bags of treats, and a chew, curated from each month’s unique themed collection. And the best part? If your dog isn’t 100% happy with their BarkBox, they’ll work with you to make it right because their mission is to have no disappointed pups.

What’s the cost?

You can subscribe starting at $22 per box and each one is valued at over $40! And as a bonus, you’ll also enjoy free shipping if you live in the contiguous 48 United States. With over 2 million happy pups, we have to say, this is a great option for any fur baby that’s waiting for a new cardboard box at home!

white dog wearing pirate collar with barkbox in background

“My pup, Susan, absolutely loves her BarkBox! She will not stop carrying around her new squeaking toy all through the house. I have ordered BarkBoxes in the past, and I have always been impressed with the quality and variety of them. I sometimes buy toys from brick and mortar stores, but Susan’s favorites are consistently the ones that arrive in the BarkBoxes. I highly recommend BarkBox to anyone looking to get their furry friends a gift (or looking to get the parents of a furry friend a gift)!”

– Lacey ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


2. Super Chewer by BarkBox

Super Chewer Chewy Subscription box

What is Super Chewer box?

Do you have a pup who loves to chew on all the things? The BarkBox Super Chewer Box provides the toughest toys that your dog will actually enjoy and they’re even backed by their 100% satisfaction guarantee – if a toy isn’t tough enough, they’ll replace it for FREE – any time, no questions asked. Plus, in each box, you’ll get nothing but the best treats made right here in the USA.

What’s the cost?

Choose between 3 different plans (12 or 6 months, or monthly) and subscribe for as low as $29/box. Every box brings your dog more than $45 worth of goodies, including 2 full-size bags of treats, 2 toys, and 2 meaty chews which will ship immediately. Every box following the first one will ship on the 15th of every month. As a bonus, you’ll also enjoy free shipping if you live in the contiguous 48 United States.

We’re always sharing great deals on BarkBox Super Chewer Boxes so we’ll be sure to keep you posted on any new deals that pop up!

Hip Tip: Already have a subscription and want to gift one to someone else? Head over to their site where you can send a box or even an eGift to a friend or family’s dog.

dog smelling toys and treats from super chewer subscription box

“We love Super Chewer so much, it’s definitely our favorite subscription box! Everything we’ve ever received has been high-quality including the toys. We literally have a super chewer (Chewy the Poodle lol) and he loves everything included! The toys are indestructible and the treats come in cute shapes.” 

– Lina ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


3. Bullymake Box

brown and white dog sitting next to bullymake box

What is Bullymake Box?

With Bullymake, you’ll not only get to choose your monthly subscription plan, but you’ll get to totally customize your Bullymake experience. You’ll get the choice to help Bullymake understand your pup so they’re getting a box that’s right for them – from their weight, allergies, and even toy preferences, or you can just choose what you want to receive in your box. Plus, they only manufacture and ship long-lasting chew toys that are durable so you can guarantee the stuff will be good for any pup.

What’s the cost?

Boxes start at $31 and go up to $39 a month depending on the plan you choose. Get a new box either every month, 3 months, 6 or 12 months – the choice is yours. And they even offer a 14-day durability and satisfaction guarantee.

dog chewing on pink bulymake heart

“Our two very large dogs love to see the box when it’s delivered! They are excited to see the month’s surprise and the toys always hold up for a long time with our extreme power chewers. These toys have outlasted any “store-bought” toy we have ever purchased. It’s really a toss-up between the treats and toys – the pups love both. Highly recommend this box!”

– Audra ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


Just looking for one box? These 2 boxes are our faves and don’t require monthly delivery:

1. Chewy Goody Box

dog smelling chewy birthday goodie box

What is Chewy Goody Box?

Whether you’re looking for a holiday-themed box, a birthday surprise box, or just an everyday box stuffed with goodies, Chewy has a few different options that will be sure to bring a wag to your pup’s tail! Each box contains three treats, two toys, and one bandana from top brands so you know that your dog will love what they’re getting. Plus, you can guarantee that the included treats are always made with wholesome ingredients such as premium salmon and natural peanut butter that they’ll go crazy for!

What’s the cost?

Each box rings in at $24.99, but is packed full of goodies worth over $40! You’ll never be so happy to save when you’re getting the very best treats for your pup. Plus, you’ll get FREE 1- to 2-day shipping on every Goody Box order!

two dogs sniffing chewy goodie box

“I’ve ordered other subscription boxes in the past and I’ve never been overly enthusiastic about the contents, but this one is so adorable – it’s definitely a cute box full of fun treats for pups! The moment I opened the box I had three eager dogs shoving their heads inside and there were even enough treats and toys for everyone. One dog is still carrying around his Halloween toy from our latest box. I tried to get a couple of pictures but I couldn’t get the dogs to keep their heads out of the box! HAHA!”

– Matt ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


2. Petmate Goodie Box

Petmate subscription boxes with treats and toys

What is it Petmate Goodie Box?

Want to just be totally surprised?! Then the Petmate Goodie Box may be the perfect one for you! They have boxes specifically for dogs and even boxes just for cats and each box has 10 different items to keep your pet happy and engaged. These mystery boxes may include collars, leashes, toys, bowls, waste management, and more.

What’s the cost?

Each box is $24 plus S&H and is valued at about $60! If you place an order of $49 or more, you’ll even get free shipping and you’ll won’t have to worry about being charged every month since you only buy a box when you actually want it! It’s a win, win for everyone.

Hip Tip: Valid now until 12/31/19, you can score a Goodie Box for your dog or cat for just $19.99 + S&H using our promo code DOGGIFT for dog boxes and CATGIFT for cat boxes.

assortment of dog toys on table

“I ended up getting 3 boxes – one large and 2 medium. I figured I would get a few nice things for our dogs, but WOW, was I amazed at all the goodies we got! The quality is also great and the items are fabulous. This is probably the best deal for the price I have ever found! I received so much stuff that some will be donated to our favorite rescue!” 

– Katie ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐


Click here to see all of our favorite subscription boxes!

Join The Discussion

Comments 18

  1. Ashley

    I did a 3 month subscription to Super Chewer Bark box, but cancelled a few weeks ago. Customer services was great, products were cute, but they just don’t last. Most of what my pup got was destroyed the first day, replacements sent, and those also destroyed immediately. I even went with the larger toys for my pup who is 49 lbs. I hope they can come up with toys that last, because the employees themselves were great, and I’d LOVE to have great toys for my dog. But I’d caution against them for now if your dog is really a super chewer.

    • Amber (Hip Sidekick)

      Darn! Thanks SO much for the helpful warning, Ashley! Hoping one of the other subscription boxes work better for your pup if you decide to give them a try.

    • Carrie S

      I agree with you Ashely! I had little pieces of rubber all over my house with in a hour of given my dog her toys from the Super Chewer box. They made me pre pay for 6 months so I’m afraid I’ll have to deal with this for the next 5 months :(. I really don’t want any replacement because I’ll just have to clean those up too.

      • Ashley

        Tell them the situation! Maybe they’ll let you cancel/refund? I had to commit to 3 months, but was billed once a month. Customer service really was great for us. But yes, they don’t last for super chewers. I can’t image what my dog could do to their regular box! It’s a lot of money for an hour of fun (max) and a mess to clean up.

        • Benji

          Ashley, did you now that we have a Scout’s Honor promise to get replacements out if anything gets destroyed? We also have the ability to TAILor your boxes for the materials and toys that work best for your pup. Reach out to Happy@SuperChewer.com and chat with us about it!

      • Benji

        Carrie, we’re sorry to hear you didn’t have the best experience with your boxes. It sounds like your pup may have done better with harder nylon materials or tougher rubbers. We have a TAILored program that can mark needs and preferences for those types of toys! Feel free to reach out to Happy@SuperChewer.com and we would love to tell you all about it and see what we can do.

    • Meranda

      That’s happens to us too!! I love the super chewer box though because of the customer service. My dog just also has too much fun tearing the toys apart so I feel bad taking that away from him, hahaha

    • Ashley Rose

      I’ve been sending email after email trying to get my money refunded from my last BarkBox. They apparently don’t respond well to asking for refunds. They now aren’t answering any of my emails. I don’t think they’d let u cancel early. I’ve not been impressed with them at all. I wish I’d realized I was signing up for a six month subscription. I thought it was just the one month and I can cancel.

      • Benji

        Ashley, it’s never our intention to make our customers feel ignored. I’m very sorry that there’s been a delay in getting in touch with you. We would be more than happy to speak with you and see what we can do to make this right for you and your pup if you can reach out to Happy@SuperChewer.com.

    • Benji

      Hey Ashley! We’re sorry to hear you had such a negative experience with your BarkBox toys. We always appreciate hearing feedback from our subscribers. One of the great things about designing new toys each and every month is that we have a new chance to improve each month based on what we hear from our awesome customers.

      Did you know we have a TAILored program now that can customize materials and even assortments? We’d love to talk with you more about it. Feel free to reach out to Happy@SuperChewer.com to speak with us. 🙂

  2. Diana

    We have ordered the Bark Box before, but my labs would chew the stuffy and leave a mess. We then ordered the Super Chewer Box, a 12 month subscription, and even these rubber toys are chewed to bits! Literal bits, everywhere. I’m ready to be done with my subscription only because the toys last a short time in our house. Customer service is great, but not enough for me to renew the next go around. My labs need to be toy testers or I need to invent toys that are “lab tested and approved!” 😉

    • Benji

      Diana, we’re always looking to hear feedback from our customers about their Super Chewer experiences. After all, when your pup gets ahold of those toys, lab-tested is exactly what they are. Please reach out to Happy@SuperChewer.com and we’d be happy to see what we can do to improve your boxes and hear what we can make better for you.

  3. shop4mybabies

    i’m going to order the petmate goodie box for my mutt for christmas.

  4. Susan31652

    We did 6 months of Barkbox. The toys are great, and I was able to ask them to not send treats as I am selective about what our dog eats. We did get one box of the same theme twice, which was disappointing, but they sent a new box out at no cost. They do sell some Barkbox toys at Target, so I am able to buy what I like. Many of the toys have another toy inside them, and it worries me to think about my idiot dog eating through a toy to find another.

    • Benji

      Susan, we’re so happy to hear your boxes have been a hit. We totally understand your hesitation about those dual layer toys. Did you know we can TAILor your box to exclude toy-in-toy toys along with that no-treat TAILoring? Just reach out to Happy@BarkBox.com!

  5. Tina

    Ditto what everyone is saying about the Super Chewer Bark Box. My puppy destroyed the toys in no time at all. For those of you who have super chewing dogs who are bound and determined to kill every toy they come across, I highly recommend Goughnuts toys. You can find them on the manufacturers website or on Amazon. They are pricey but they last, in fact we’ve had toys for months that have zero signs of wear. If your dog manages to damage the Goughnuts they have an awesome warranty. Check them out!

    • Benji

      Tina, did you know that our Super Chewer boxes have a 100% replacement policy to help keep the fun going? We know that no toy is indestructible, but we want to do our best to work with you to find the best TAILoring options and replacements to make playtime last. Reach out to Happy@SuperChewer.com and we can get you all set up with something new.

  6. Summer

    I am with the group on the Super Chewers and my black lab completely destroying the toys so quickly. A huge mess and really … why would I want another one for him to eat, as a replacement?! It comes out either in the yard or because he ate it, he throws it up. I disagree with them being for “super chewers.” Fortunately mine was a gift. I am going to try the Goughnuts! Thanks for the info Tina!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

It's not your Grandma's coupon site!

Sign up for a Hip2Save account (it's free) to access all of the awesome features!

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot Password

Don't have an account? Register

Become a Hip2Save Insider

Don't Miss Out! Join our large community of insiders - it's totally free! Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! What are ya waiting for?!

Already have an account? Login

Become a Hip2Save Insider

Don't Miss Out! Join our large community of insiders - it's totally free! Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! What are ya waiting for?!



Already have an account? Login

Thank you for rating!

Would you also like to leave us a comment?