See Which 5 Best-Selling Amazon Sandals Our Team is Raving About

Hip2Save may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you via trusted partners and affiliate links in this post. Prices and availability are accurate as of time posted. Read our full disclosure policy here.

feet wearing red braided sandals with red toenail polish

If you’ve been following our fun Amazon team try-ons, you know we’re loving the trendy styles Amazon has to offer! To go with those super fun shirts and dresses from past posts, here are chic and comfy best-selling sandals we tried from Amazon. These will be your new summer staples on vacation, at work, at the pool, and on your date night!

1. Lina’s sandals

feet in strappy sandals with painted red toenails

MEGNYA Women’s Comfortable Flat Walking Sandals$25.51-$39.99 

Summer is full of adventure, so if you need the perfect shoe to make the trek, these are perfect! These waterproof sandals are great for hiking the trails, going to the beach, or walking around a cruise ship – you name it, they’re ready for it!

Here’s what Lina had to say about her Amazon sandals:

“I love these walking sandals! They have a lot of heel and arch support, and they’re so cushy to walk on. I’ve been wearing them on vacation and they are great casual sandals, overall. I’m just so impressed with how super comfortable and cute they are! I wouldn’t recommend sizing up, because I found that they do stretch a bit.” 

2. Emily’s sandals

feet wearing wedge sandals black straps

SODA Women’s Open Toe Ankle Strap Espadrille Sandal | $15-$55

These Amazon sandals are identical to the $80 Steve Madden pair we’ve all been eyeing up over here, except they come in over 50 different colors – and they’re less than half the cost! Perfect for dressing up any casual summer outfit (or take them on your next getaway)!

amazon and steve madden price comparison on black sandals

Here’s what Emily had to say about her Amazon sandals:

“Do your closet a favor and buy these sandals! I’ve been wanting a pair like this since last summer, and I’m so happy they were available for such a great price. The quality is awesome, and all the details look just like the designer pair I’ve been eyeing. They’re also comfortable for all-day wear! I can’t wait to get them in another color!”

3. Erica’s sandals

feet wearing grey braided sandals with pink toenail polish

Plaka Flat Sandals for Women Palm Leaf | $24.95-$34.95

Stylish rope sandals are a perfect way to dress up any outfit, and with 20 different color variations available on Amazon, there’s definitely a sandal to go with every one of your outfits this summer!

Erica’s Hip Tip: I have a chunkier-type foot, so when I first put these on they felt tight, and I was concerned they weren’t going to work out. I wore them around the house first, and within 30-45 minutes, they broke in so quickly!

Here’s what Erica had to say about her Amazon sandals:

“These sandals are so stinkin’ CUTE! I’m seriously obsessed with them! I love all the straps and handwoven braids – they totally scream ‘SUMMER’! Oh, and they would be such a great gift since they come wrapped up in a cute canvas bag!”

4. Michelle’s sandals

feet wearing dark green sandals in grass

DREAM PAIRS Women’s Elastic Ankle Strap Flat Sandals$14.99-$26.99

These strappy shoes will have you feeling like you’re walking on air! If you’re looking for the perfect summer staple for your wardrobe, these sandals come in 11 different colors and will make accessorizing easy breezy.

Here’s what Michelle had to say about her Amazon sandals:

“I thought these would be a no go after seeing them in the package, but they are surprisingly really comfortable! They feel like I’m not even wearing shoes and give a great casual look to any outfit. (I wouldn’t recommend them for walking long distances.) For around 15 bucks and tons of colors to choose from, I think they’re totally worth it!” 

5. Sara’s sandals

mirrored image on feet wearing white sandals and round fringe black rug

Shoe Land SL-Greece Women’s Flat Sandals Slides$15.99-$21.99

I love an amazing knockoff find, so I was over the moon when I found my favorite Steve Madden lookalike sandals on Amazon for way less! They’re so trendy and chic right now, you’re going to love these for any summer outfit, plus they come in a few different colors.

Hip Tip: I found these sandals to be very true to size. I ordered an 8, which is my regular size. However, they are narrow (which is also stated next to each size online). I would NOT recommend them for anyone with a wider foot, as they would be extremely uncomfortable and won’t likely fit.

white cut out sandals amazon and steve madden comparison

Here’s what I had to say about my Amazon sandals:

“I brought these sandals to the beach and got so many compliments. Plus, they look just like the Steve Madden pair I had been obsessing over forever! These aren’t ideal for long walks, but I think once they’re broken in, they’ll be perfect!”

Don’t forget those toes, ladies! Here are our favorite nail polish colors for summer:

row of nail polish colors red pink dark blue and white

  1. Lina’s pick – OPI “Big Apple Red”
  2. Emily’s pick – Essie “Watermelon”
  3. Erica’s pick – OPI “Color So Hot It Burns”
  4. Michelle’s pick – Ella + Mila “Mediterranian Mist”
  5. Sara’s pick – OPI “Alpine Snow”

Come see the popular Amazon dresses that our team tried!

About the writer:

Sara is a self-taught blogger & photographer and brings 9+ years of experience to her craft. Her work has been featured in numerous esteemed publications, spanning building, travel, and fashion. Beyond her creative pursuits, Sara’s primary mission is to empower others to embrace a toxic-free & sustainable lifestyle.

Join The Discussion

Comments 20

  1. Leavesbegintofall

    I have the plaka. And they are sooooo cute! I loved them so much. I’m an 8 1/2 and ordered a size 8. I would say I have average to narrow width feet and the straps loosened up so much that they fall off often, which is really sad for me, because I love the way they look. When I did wear them, I got tons of compliments. I wish the straps were adjustable.

    • Amber (Hip Sidekick)

      Those sure are cute!! Sorry to hear how loose the straps have become! Thanks for letting us know!

  2. Stephanie

    Thanks for the recommendations! Just ordered Lina’s pair for delivery tomorrow! I’m 7 months along and have been searching Amazon for a pair of comfy walking sandals to help my achy feet— this post couldn’t have came at a better time! I appreciate it!

    • Collin (Mrs. Hip)

      You’re very welcome! How exciting! Congratulations, Stephanie! Hope you love them!

    • centerofattn315

      I got them last week and have been wearing ever since – so comfy and good support.

  3. gege1804

    The last white one is so cute.

    • Amber (Hip Sidekick)

      I’m loving those too! Thanks for stopping by to check out our list!

  4. Tori

    Any for wide feet?

    • Lizzie

      Have you checked out Walmart? They have severa “trendy” styles right now that come in wide widths at my Walmart. And at less than $10, I wanted to buy them all!

      • Tori

        Thanks! Since Payless closed it gets harder to find wides you can try on.

  5. Kass

    I have the plaka sandals and love them. I always get so many compliments when I wear them.

    • Jennifer (Hip Sidekick)

      Awesome! They are super cute, Kass!

  6. Jean

    Love that you added the nail polish colors!!

    • Jennifer (Hip Sidekick)

      Thanks for letting us know, Jean!

  7. Jeangirl

    I’m not an amazon prime member. does anyone know the return policy if they don’t fit right? thank you:)

  8. Corina

    Thanks for posting! I love Lina’s MEGNYA sandals and they are in my cart. I appreciate you posting the nail polish colors too! I followed the link to Erica’s pick – OPI “Color So Hot It Burns” and it was on sale at Target and I scooped it up with another color. Thank you!

    • Collin (Mrs. Hip)

      Yay! That’s great to hear, Corina! You’re SO very welcome!

  9. Deal lover

    For Emily’s pick, are the Soda sandals true to size?

    • Emily (Hip Sidekick)

      They are! I’m normally an 8-8.5 and I went with a size 8 for the sandals and they fit perfectly.

  10. Nikole Paquette

    I highly recommend the Plaka sandal and I have a wide foot. Love mine!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

It's not your Grandma's coupon site!

Sign up for a Hip2Save account (it's free) to access all of the awesome features!

Forgot Password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot Password

Don't have an account? Register

Become a Hip2Save Insider

Don't Miss Out! Join our large community of insiders - it's totally free! Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! What are ya waiting for?!

Already have an account? Login

Thank you for rating!

Would you also like to leave us a comment?