Quince vs. Caraway: Can This $80 Ceramic Nonstick Set Really Compete?

Read my review of Quince’s cookware – non-stick & toxin-free. 

Looking to switch to non-toxic cookware without spending a fortune? After 4 years of cooking with Caraway, I put Quince’s Ceramic Nonstick Cookware to the test to see if it’s a worthy (and more affordable) alternative.

Here’s the set I ordered…

So how does Quince compare to Caraway cookware?…

As I’ve mentioned, I’ve owned my Caraway cookware for over four years, so it naturally has a bit of a disadvantage when it comes to appearance. Both Quince and Caraway use ceramic nonstick coatings that are free of PTFE (Teflon), PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium, and both are compatible with all stovetops, including induction.

One difference worth noting is that Caraway publicly shares third-party testing results for their cookware, while I have not found publicly available third-party testing reports from Quince.

Quince cookware is oven-safe up to 500°F, which is more than enough for everyday cooking, while Caraway is rated up to 550°F. In the last 4 years, I’ve only ever baked something as high as 500°F, so I feel that’s more than sufficient.

At first glance, Quince’s cookware looks almost identical to Caraway’s.

Making it a great option if you’re after that same sleek, non-toxic ceramic cookware look. The Quince handles feel a bit lighter compared to Caraway’s more substantial design, and they may heat up a little quicker while cooking.

The inside of the Quince pans also has a slightly more textured finish versus Caraway’s smooth, glossy surface, but the difference is very subtle, and I haven’t noticed it impacting the cooking experience or nonstick performance.

Another small difference I found is that Quince’s sauté pans are slightly more shallow than Caraway’s. I measured my Quince sauté pans at just under 2″ deep, while my Caraway pans measure just under 2.5″. It’s not a huge difference, but if you regularly cook larger portions, make one-pan meals, or like extra room for tossing ingredients, the additional depth of Caraway may be worth considering.

However, if you’re considering the full Quince cookware set, it does include a 3QT saucepan with lid that measures 3.9″ H without the lid. This adds some much-needed depth and versatility to the collection, making the set feel more well-rounded and capable of handling a wider variety of cooking tasks beyond just everyday sautéing and frying.

Speaking of the full sets…here’s how the price compares…

When it comes to price, this is where Quince really stands out. The Quince Ceramic Nonstick 7-Piece Cookware Set is currently $199.90 and includes:

• 10″ frying pan
• 3 qt. saucepan with lid
• 5 qt. sauté pan with lid
• 6 qt. soup pot with lid

The Caraway 12-piece Cookware Set is a much larger investment at $445 (reg. $675) and includes:

• 10.5″ fry pan
• 3 qt. saucepan with lid
• 4.5 qt. sauté pan with lid
• 6.5 qt. Dutch oven with lid
• Magnetic pan racks
• Canvas lid organizer

While Caraway does include those premium storage accessories and a slightly larger Dutch oven, Quince gives you very similar core cookware pieces, including a larger sauté pan and soup pot, for less than half the price.

Overall, I think Quince is a seriously impressive alternative for anyone looking to make the switch to non-toxic ceramic cookware without the premium price tag.

While Caraway still has the edge when it comes to little details like the heavier feel, deeper sauté pan, color options, storage accessories, and publicly shared third-party testing, Quince delivers a very similar cooking experience for a fraction of the cost.

If you’re building a non-toxic kitchen on a budget, I think the Quince cookware set is a great option that gives you the features most people are looking for without the Caraway price point.

Check out these other Quince products we love!